DUTCH HEALTH INVESTIGATION : STAFFORDSHIRE BULL TERRIERS
by Bianca van Londen

“... Only 2% of the dogs named are listed in the dangerous dog list ...”


In The Netherlands the popularity of the Staffordshire Bull Terrier has decreased tremendously between 2001 and 2002. The table on the right shows the registration entries at the Dutch Kennel Club for the period 1989 to 2003.

TABLE 1
Year
Registered
Year
Registered
Year
Registered
1989
269
1994
357
1999
677
1990
263
1995
493
2000
663
1991
251
1996
660
2001
912
1992
318
1997
636
2002
673
1993
348
1998
741
2003
851

The Dutch Staffordshire Bull Terrier Club wanted to know if there were any health problems concerning structure or behaviour. Just like any other breed, the Staffordshire Bull Terrier has deformities or diseases that are hereditary, or are supposed to have a hereditary origin. The essential question was that if there were found to be health or behaviour problems in the breed, then was direct action desirable or necessary? The investigation started in 2002 and standardized questionnaire forms were used. A total of 741 were sent out of which 283 forms (38,2%) were returned - enough of a return to draw useful and meaningful conclusions.

The direct aims from this health investigation were:

1 To establish what the biggest health problems in the Dutch population of Staffordshire Bull Terriers were.
2 To estimate the frequency that these problems occur.
3 To indicate conclusions and recommendations to breeders and the Breed Club.

To commence the health investigation, the known problems were evaluated. Based on this, it was concluded that those problems occur mostly before the age of four years - hence owners of Staffordshire Bull Terriers born in 1999 were asked to participate in the investigation. The ratio of bitch to dog was almost 1:1. This is an important fact because a shortage of males could indicate a sex-related hereditary disease.

Of the 237 Staffordshire Bull Terriers that participated in this health investigation:

1 237 (85,3%) were purchased from a breeder.
2 24 (8,6%) were homebred.
3 17 (6,1%) were bought from a third party.

As health investigations are also conducted in other breeds some results are good to compare. The percentage of Staffordshire Bull Terriers bought through a third party is high compared to other breeds - apparently the people who originally bought these dogs are not very motivated to raise a puppy, or the Staffordshire Bull Terrier didn’t live up to their expectations (which could indicate no or insufficient information supplied by the breeders). Only 1% of the investigated age group weren’t alive anymore - which compared to other breeds is a very low percentage.

Health

The first question in this part of the investigation was if the dog had ever had any kind of health problem. Of the 279 owners who answered this question, 73 (26,2%) stated that they had experienced a health problem - again, related to other breeds this is a low percentage. These health problems varied from very minor problems to life-threatening problems such as kidney failure or heart deformities.

Health problems by anatomic function

Table 2 shows the results, split by anatomic function.

TABLE 2
Born
Skin &
Hair

number (%)
Spinal
Column

number (%)
Limbs
number (%)
Teeth
number (%)
Nervous
System

number (%)
Eyes/Visual
Faculty

number (%)
Ears &
Hearing

number (%)
Blood &
Defence
System

number (%)
Heart &
Vascular
System

number (%)
1999
36
(12,9%)
2
(0,7%)
16
(5,7%)
6
(2,2%)
2
(0,7%)
5
(1,8%)
2
(0,7%)
0
(0%)
0
(0%)
 
Lungs &
Bronchial
Tubes

number (%)
Alimentary
Canal

number (%)
Kidneys &
Urinary
Passages

number (%)
Milk
Scrofulous

number (%)
Sexual
Organs

number (%)
Repro-
duction

number (%)
Hormones
numbers (%)
Liver
number (%)
Behaviour
number (%)
 
8
(2,9%)
3
(1,1%)
1
(0,4%)
0
(0%)
7
(2,5%)
1
(0,4%)
4
(1,4%)
0
(0%)
4
(1,4%)

Table 2 shows that in the Skin & Hair category 36 Staffordshire Bull Terriers were affected - this is 12,9%, or better said, 1 out of every 8 Staffords that took part in the investigation. The next important problem area is the Limbs category where 16 Staffords were affected (5,7%).

Breed specific health problems

Like any other breed, the SBT also has some hereditary diseases that, right or wrongly, are mentioned in one breath with the breed’s name. In the health investigation these diseases were summed up and specifically asked about. The results of the investigation don’t really confirm those assumptions.

TABLE 3
Born
Hip
Dysplasia

number (%)
Epilepsy
number (%)
Patella
Luxation

number (%)
Cruciate Ligament /
Hamstring Lesion

number (%)
Allergy
number (%)
1999
1
(0,4%)
2
(0,7%)
1
(0,4%)
11
(3,9%)
16
(5,7%)
 
Elongated
Soft Palate

number (%)
Vocal Cord
Paralysis

number (%)
Inverted
Canines

number (%)
Overshot
number (%)
Undershot
number (%)
 
2
(0,7%)
0
(0%)
1
(0,4%)
2
(0,7%)
2
(0,7%)

Table 3 shows that for the Stafford allergy is the most common disease (16 SBTs or 5,7%). The second most common defect is cruciate ligament/hamstring lesions (11 dogs or 3,9%). The other diseases which had been thought to play a part in the Dutch SBT population, didn’t or only had a very small percentage. Of course this doesn’t mean that some of these diseases don’t matter because of the relatively simple way they can be passed on within a few generations and become serious problems.

Health problems per sex - dogs compared to bitches

Table 4 shows the health problems by sex. It shows that dogs suffer more health problems than bitches - 62 occurrences in dogs, 36 occurrences in bitches.

 TABLE 4   
System
Dogs
number (%)
Bitches
number (%)
Total Number
Skin & Hair
21
(15%)
15
(10,8%)
36
Spinal Column
2
(1,4%)
0
(0%)
2
Limbs
10
(7,1%)
6
(4,3%)
16
Teeth (dentition)
5
(3,6%)
1
(0,7%)
6
Nervous System
2
(1,4%)
0
(0%)
2
Eyes & Visual Faculty
3
(2,1%)
2
(1,4%)
5
Ears & Hearing
2
(1,4%)
0
(0%)
2
Blood & Defence System
0
(0%)
0
(0%)
0
Heart & Vascular System
0
(0%)
0
(0%)
0
Lungs & Bronchial Tubes
6
(4,3%)
2
(1,4%)
8
Alimentary Canal
1
(0,7%)
2
(1,4%)
3
Kidneys & Urinary Passages
1
(0,7%)
0
(0%)
1
Milk Scrofulous
0
(0%)
0
(0%)
0
Sexual Organs
4
(2,9%)
3
(2,2%)
7
Reproduction
0
(0%)
1
(0,7%)
1
Hormones
2
(1,4%)
2
(1,4%)
4
Liver
0
(0%)
1
(0,7%)
1
Behaviour
3
(2,1%)
1
(0,7%)
4
TOTALS
62
36
98

Behaviour

To get a good idea of the overall behaviour and temperament of the Staffordshire Bull Terrier, the investigators made a list of descriptive characteristics. The owner was asked to choose the characteristics that best described his Stafford. This question was answered by 279 persons. It results gave a picture of how the average SBT owner experiences the behaviour of his dog.

Based on these results the average Stafford is seen as a friendly, gay and affectionate dog. These typical characteristics were chosen by 80% of the owners. For more than 60% it was stated that the Stafford was also “active”. Compared to other breeds the SBT scores highly on the positive features of temperament.

On the other hand, the Stafford does have some not so appreciated features - but it is interesting to note that for a dog who was originally bred to fight (but never used on humans, unlike certain other breeds, such as some guard dog breeds) characteristics such “fierce”, “grumpy” and “the will to bite” were only mentioned in a very few cases. Some dogs in the study group were described as scared (6,5%) or nervous (6,5%).

Behaviour in relationship to sex

In dogs it is assumed that there are differences in behaviour between males and females. To see how marked this is in SBTs, the characteristics chosen between dogs and bitches were compared as you can see in Table 5. Although it is hard to justify, there is an indication that bitches have a higher rating in the characteristic “fear”, but for all other characteristics the percentages are mostly equal.

In breeding it is important that we look at scared and nervous bitches, because these traits can be passed on to the next generations in two ways. This undesirable behaviour can have an hereditary cause and can be passed on to the puppies by either the mother or the father. Besides this, the mother teaches her own behaviour to her puppies. A nervous or scared mother, regardless of whether her own conduct comes from an hereditary source or is caused by environmental factors, will almost always teach her puppies the same behaviour. It is of utmost importance to withdraw these bitches from breeding. It is also better to not put nervous or scared dogs at stud.

TABLE 5
Characteristic/Feature
Dogs
number (%)
Bitches
number (%)
Total Number
Quiet
58
(41,4%)
62
(44,6%)
120
Active
82
(58,6%)
70
(50,4%)
152
Nervous
10
(7,1%)
8
(5,8%)
18
Fierce
3
(2,1%)
3
(2,1%)
6
Grumpy
2
(1,4%)
0
(0%)
2
Bite Tendency
1
(0,7%)
1
(0,7%)
2
Scared
5
(3,6%)
13
(9,4%)
18
Gay
113
(80,7%)
115
(82,7%)
228
Affectionate
117
(83,6%)
122
(87,1%)
239
Friendly
122
(87,1%)
122
(87,1%)
244
Lively
86
(64,1%)
87
(62,6%)
173
Different
5
(3,6%)
4
(2,.9%)
9

Obedience

Another question in the health investigation was how the owners find the obedience level of their dogs. To specify this they could choose from five offered characteristics, from “very good” to “very bad”. Almost every SBT owner in the group indicated that their dog was “good” to “very good”. Only a small percentage (8,0%) were stated to be “moderate” to “very bad”.

TABLE 6
Born
Very Good
number (%)
Good
number (%)
Moderate
number (%)
Bad
number (%)
Very Bad
number (%)
Total
Number
Number
No Answer
1999
106
(38,4%)
147
(53,3%)
21
(7,6%)
2
(0,7%)
0
(0%)
276
7

Breeding

In this section the investigators attempted to “see” what the expectations for the future are based upon the breeding behaviour of the investigated group. By doing this they assumed that the breeding behaviour of the dogs in the period investigated would be representative for the Staffordshire Bull Terriers currently being bred.

Number of breeding animals and their contribution

Table 7 shows that only a small percentage of the dogs had offspring.

TABLE 7
  DOGS:  BITCHES: 
Born
With Offspring
number (%)
Without Offspring
number (%)
Total
Dogs
With Offspring
number (%)
Without Offspring
number (%)
Total
Bitches
1999
11
(7,9%)
129
(92,1%)
140
28
(20,4%)
109
(79,6%)
137

Much more important than percentages are numbers. It is desirable that the inbreeding coefficient is kept low to decrease, or at least maintain, the hereditary variety. What isn’t shown by the figures is the family relationship between the dogs used breeding. The deviation from born litters split over dogs and bitches only gives a small view to the level in which breeders tend to practise inbreeding. The popularity of often used stud dogs doesn’t stop with the mating. It seems acceptable that descendants from the most popular stud dogs take a larger part in the breeding on the following generations than the descendants from not so popular stud dogs. This causes the effect of excessive use of stud dogs in the following generations. A limited number of stud dogs contribute at first directly, and later on indirectly by their descendants, an unbalanced contribution to the genetic material in future generations.

The Stafford comes forward out of the “Health” chapter with the best results from the breeds investigated so far. This was reason enough for the investigators to look for an answer in comparison to the other investigated breeds. It showed that in the Stafford population a greater number of the available stud dogs are used (circa 15 %), and that more bitches (28%) where used for breeding compared to other breeds (3 to 8% for dogs, and 10 to 20% for bitches). The investigators think that the fact of the employment of more animals has contributed greatly to the preservation of the quality of health in the breed.

Fertility

In the stud dogs, 17 matings were reported which all resulted in the birth of a litter. Artificial insemination wasn’t used. From the 15 litters the stud dogs’ owners reported, none were born by caesarian.

In the brood bitches, 35 matings where reported, of which 35 resulted in the birth of a litter. Artificial insemination was used once. From the 32 litters the brood bitches’ owners reported, 5 were born by caesarian.

It is interesting to note that the stud dog owners gave a more positive impression on numbers of born, deceased and weaned puppies, than that given by the brood bitch owners.

The quality of the breeding animals

If speaking on the quality of the breeding animals in relation to this health investigation, we mean quality in terms of health. Health (or the lack of health) is largely determined by hereditary factors. Shortcomings in breeding stock will often appear again in direct descendants or even in later generations.